Archive for November, 2011

More Analysis of the Farmland Market

Friday, November 25th, 2011

On November 15th, the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago hosted a conference entitled “Rising Farmland Values – Causes and Cautions”.  A series of prominent economists, professors, lenders, and other industry professionals were invited to offer their view of the current state of the farmland marketplace in the Midwest.  Many of the  presentations can be found and downloaded here (Chicago Fed Ag Conference) by clicking on the “Agenda” tab.

I’m the first to admit that there are several different methods for discussing and analyzing the land value issue. Some experts have taken reams of historical data and neatly summarized the whole story in a series of charts and graphs.  Others have taken the more simplified approach of simply talking with land buyers and land sellers to see what’s been motivating their behavior.  When looking at the issue from this angle, it appears the biggest driver in ag land values has been the increase in farm income.  No doubt there are other forces at play, e.g., the risk/return of alternative investments, etc., but it still boils down to the fact that farmers have been making more money and they’ve invested a large part of their profits into new land purchases (or higher rents, thus stabilizing the returns to investors).

The future direction of land values is uncertain (though I personally feel that the rapid increase we’ve seen the past 5 years is going to level off) and I encourage all farmers and investors to continue reading and studying the issue closely.  But when you get to the point when your head is ready to explode from information overload, just remember the basics – if farmers are making money, land values will remain steady and/or move higher.  When they aren’t, especially for an extended period of time, then it’s time to get worried.

Keeping Record Land Prices in Perspective

Friday, November 11th, 2011

Recently, a 120 acre farm in Sioux County, Iowa auctioned for 16,750 dollars per acre.  Considered a record price for farmland in Iowa, this sale follows numerous other sales across the Midwest of over $10,000 per acre. The question to be asked is: how and why are farms trading hands at $2,000, $3,000, or even $5,000 above similar properties in different areas?

An overview of the Sioux County sale recently appeared on the dtnprogressivefarmer.com website (Crazy Sioux County Land Auction Strikes Again).  As Marcia Zarley Taylor points out, the ag economy in this part of NW Iowa is unique – grain farmers have been making money, but the livestock sector is thriving as well. Many brokers and appraisers called this sale an abnormality, yet whenever you have several financially strong buyers all looking to purchase land in a specific location, the final sale price can be significantly higher than recent sales elsewhere.

Across the Midwest, all the record high prices the past 12 months have had the same common theme – the farm is ideally situated in an area where at least 2 farmers are willing and able to pay a premium for its location.  In many cases, these potential buyers adjoin the subject parcel or have driven their equipment by it for years hoping for the chance to own it someday.  In some areas, land seldom comes for sale and buyers know that they must buy now if they hope to buy at all. And sometimes, unusual variables come into play – a farmer wants to expand his livestock operation but must have additional land to spread the waste.

In all the situations mentioned above, location is the most important variable. Move a farm 5 miles in any direction and the sale price may be 25% lower… simply because the neighbors are different.  Or stated differently, record prices can be explained by looking at who the neighbors are; and non-record prices can be explained by looking at who the neighbors aren’t.  Landowners looking to sell in the next few months should keep this in mind – not every sale will set a record so make sure to set your expectations accordingly.

Increase in Farms for Sale

Friday, November 4th, 2011

If you look in your local classifieds section, or better yet, the Auction Section for an Ag publication like Illinois AgriNews, you will notice more farms for sale this fall than we have seen the last few years.  In 2007/2008, the farmland market saw glut of properties come on the market as landowners looked to cash in on then-record high prices.  When the economic problems hit in the summer of 2008, the activity in the farmland market screeched to a halt like every other market in the world.  While the residential real estate market’s problems were caused by bad loans being given out, lax lending practices, and overbuilding, the slow down in the farm real estate sector was primarily driven by a sharp drop in the corn and bean markets.

In 2009 and 2010, the supply of available farms was extremely thin, which actually helped keep the market strong.  However, in the last 12 months, there has been a noticeable increase in the number of farms on the market.  The main reason?  It again comes back to corn and soybean prices.  We saw the markets start to nudge up in late 2010 and then explode in early 2011, allowing more income to flow towards farmers.  We’ve seen farmers reinvest these higher profits back into their operations by buying land.  Farmers are not the only buying group, however.  Investors banking on a continued worldwide population growth (we’ve just passed 7 billion and are projected to pass 9 billion by 2050), are viewing farmland as strong long-term investment.  As population increases, food is going to be more in demand, which means the ground that the food is produced on is going to be more in demand.

All of these factors have caused farm prices to jump considerably the last 12 months.  Sellers who may have felt like they may have missed their chance to sell before prices dropped in 2008 may look to cash out now that their land value has come back (and surpassed the high prices we saw in 2007).  Unlike in some years, where some owners were looking to sell by the end of the year for tax purposes, sellers are not showing that urgency this year.  I think there is a good chance we will see a continued strong supply of farms on the market into 2012.  From that point, it will depend on how the commodities markets perform.